My Favorite Pizza in Pleasanton

Pleasanton’s Must-Try Pizza Spots: A Local Guide from Gina Piper

If you’re house-hunting in Pleasanton or already lucky enough to call this charming East Bay town home, you’ve probably noticed the abundance of incredible places to eat. Among them? Pizza. And not just any pizza—Pleasanton serves up some of the best slices around, representing a wide range of styles from classic Neapolitan to bold fusion.

As someone who lives and works right here in Pleasanton, I’ve had the pleasure (and let’s be honest, joy!) of trying out many of the local pizza favorites. Here’s a curated list of where to find the best pizza in Pleasanton—perfect for dinner after a day of open houses or your next weekend treat.

Locanda Amalfi – Authentic Neapolitan Pizza in the Heart of Town

📍 Locanda Amalfi

Locanda Amalfi brings true Italian craftsmanship to Pleasanton with its Neapolitan-style pizzas, baked in a wood-fired oven imported from Italy. Expect soft, chewy crusts with that perfect char, fresh tomato sauce, and creamy mozzarella. Whether you sit indoors or dine on the patio, this is a spot for those who appreciate simplicity done well.

Local favorite: The Margherita D.O.C. – light, fresh, and authentically Italian.

New York Pizza – Big City Slices Done Right

📍 New York Pizza

Missing that classic New York fold? You’re in luck. New York Pizza nails the East Coast style, complete with thin crust, crispy edges, and bold tomato sauce. It’s fast, flavorful, and consistent—a great option for a quick bite after work or during a move-in day dinner.

Go-to order: Pepperoni slice or a full pie with extra cheese.

Porky’s Pizza Palace – A Pleasanton Staple Since 1963

📍 Porky’s Pizza Palace

This longtime local favorite has been a community hangout for decades. Porky’s offers a traditional pizza style with a slightly thicker crust and generous toppings. It’s the kind of place where families gather, teams celebrate, and regulars keep coming back.

What to try: The Porky’s Special, loaded with meats and veggies.

Gay Nineties Pizza Co. – Brick-Oven Pizza in a Historic Building

📍 Gay Nineties Pizza

Housed in one of Pleasanton’s oldest buildings, Gay Nineties Pizza Co. pairs historic charm with hearty, brick-oven pizza. Their dough is hand-tossed, and the topping combos are as classic as the ambiance. It’s a fun and cozy place to bring the whole family or enjoy a laid-back date night.

Standout item: The Combination Pizza—a local classic for good reason.

Zachary’s Chicago Pizza – Deep-Dish Heaven

📍 Zachary’s Chicago Pizza

For those who prefer their pizza with layers of flavor (and cheese!), Zachary’s brings the Chicago deep-dish tradition to Pleasanton. Their stuffed pizzas are rich, indulgent, and filled with fresh, quality ingredients under a thick blanket of house-made tomato sauce.

Recommended bite: Spinach & Mushroom stuffed pizza—it’s both comforting and crowd-pleasing.

Parktown Pizza & Curry Pizza House – Spicy Fusion That Packs a Punch

📍 Parktown Pizza Company
📍 Curry Pizza House

If you’re ready to venture outside the box, Pleasanton has not one but two incredible spots for Indian-style fusion pizza. Parktown Pizza Company and Curry Pizza House blend bold South Asian spices with classic pizza crust for one-of-a-kind flavor combinations. Think butter chicken pizza, paneer tikka toppings, and sauces that deliver serious depth.

Must-try: The Tandoori Chicken Pizza – spicy, savory, and unforgettable.

Craving a New Home and Great Pizza?

Pleasanton isn’t just a beautiful place to live—it’s a foodie’s paradise, and pizza lovers have a lot to celebrate here. If you’re thinking about putting down roots in a neighborhood close to one of these delicious pizza places (or all of them!), I’d love to help you find the perfect home.

With deep local knowledge and a passion for connecting people with the Pleasanton lifestyle, I’m here to guide you through every step of the real estate journey.

Let’s talk real estate—and maybe even share a slice!
📞 Contact Gina Piper today to start your home search in Pleasanton.